electric water heater

Troubleshooting Electric Water Heater Power Problems

November 30, 20257 min read

When the water suddenly turns cold and won’t warm up again, it’s easy to assume the heater just broke. But if you’ve got an electric water heater, the issue might be more specific—power problems. These are common, especially in older homes or during colder months when electrical demand increases. Understanding what could be causing the trouble is the first step to getting hot water back and keeping household routines on track.

Electric water heaters rely on a steady flow of electricity to function correctly. Sometimes, a small interruption in the power source or a faulty component inside the unit can stop everything from working. If you’re dealing with inconsistent water temperature or no hot water at all, there are a few places to start looking. Troubleshooting early can prevent more serious damage to the system and help avoid a complete failure when you least expect it.

Keith the Plumber has helped many homeowners in Birmingham, Alabama, identify and fix electric water heater problems before they snowball. Knowing what to look for is the first step.

Common Electric Water Heater Power Problems

Before grabbing any tools or poking around your water heater, it helps to know which issues tend to show up most. Many power-related problems are linked to just a few parts of the system. Narrowing it down keeps the fix more straightforward and saves time.

Here are some of the most common power problems homeowners run into:

- Tripped Circuit Breaker

Sometimes, too much current flows through the heater and causes the breaker to trip. This cuts off the electric supply to the unit to prevent overheating or fire risks. Breakers can trip during a storm, because of an overloaded panel, or if there’s a short in the system.

- Faulty Thermostat

The thermostat controls when the heater turns on and off. If it's faulty, it might fail to signal the unit to heat the water. That means the tank could be full, but the water won’t warm up.

- Burnt-Out Heating Element

Electric water heaters often use two heating elements. If one burns out, water may still heat—just not very well. If both go out, you’ll have no hot water at all.

For example, someone might find their shower cutting to cold water faster than usual and think it’s a plumbing issue. But after checking the panel, they notice the circuit to the water heater has tripped. Resetting the breaker may restore power temporarily, but if it happens again, that’s a sign something else is going on deeper in the system.

Each of these problems has different warning signs, but catching them early helps prevent small troubles from turning into bigger ones. Once you know what to watch for, it becomes easier to spot issues before they affect your entire home.

Diagnosing The Problem

Knowing something’s wrong is one thing. Figuring out what it is takes a bit more effort. Diagnosing a power issue with an electric water heater involves a few simple but important steps. Some signs are obvious, while others take a little more digging.

Start here when trying to track down the cause:

1. Check the Circuit Breaker

Head to the home’s main electrical panel and see if the breaker for the water heater has tripped. If it’s flipped to the middle or off position, that’s likely the source of the problem. Reset it and listen for any humming sounds at the tank, which can indicate power has returned.

2. Inspect the Thermostat

If the breaker looks fine but you still don’t have hot water, the thermostat might be the issue. Some electric heaters have panels you can open to access the thermostat. If there's no click when you adjust the setting, that could be a warning sign.

3. Test the Heating Element

This step takes care and proper tools. Heating elements can be tested with a multimeter to see if they’re still working. A reading of zero means the element is bad and needs replacing. If you’re not confident using electrical tools, this is a good moment to call for help.

Electrical parts wear out over time, especially if the system runs often, like during December in Birmingham when people are at home more and using warm water for showers, dishes, and laundry. Solving smaller issues before they build up helps keep hot water ready when you need it most.

Solutions For Power Issues

Once you've figured out why your electric water heater isn't working, the next step is deciding how to fix it. Some solutions are easy enough to spot, while others require training and tools. Either way, the key is to not delay repairs.

Here are some possible fixes for common electric water heater power problems:

- Resetting the Circuit Breaker

If the breaker tripped, switching it back on might get your water heater working again. Be sure to monitor it over the next few days. If it trips again, you're likely dealing with something deeper, like a short circuit or panel overload.

- Replacing a Faulty Thermostat

A thermostat that no longer works can’t regulate the tank’s heating cycles. Trying to swap this part without experience can be risky. A certified plumber can assess the issue and install a new one safely.

- Changing a Burnt-Out Heating Element

Replacing a burnt-out heating element is more involved. It means draining the tank, removing the damaged part, and correctly installing a new element. Mistakes during this process often lead to tank damage or water leaks, so it’s best handled by someone with experience.

Fixing small issues the wrong way often turns them into bigger ones. If you suspect anything is off or your heater needs repeat resets, it's time to call in a professional. Water paired with electricity is never something to take lightly. Let certified technicians handle the more complex repairs safely and correctly.

Simple Maintenance Habits To Avoid Power Failures

Once you’ve fixed your electric water heater, the next step is doing what you can to keep it running without more surprises. Taking a bit of time to stay on top of maintenance saves money and helps you avoid another chilly morning in Birmingham.

Try the following:

- Inspect the Heater Every Few Months

Look for signs like rusted panels, leaking water, or scorch marks near wiring. These are strong clues that something’s wearing out or already damaged.

- Check Safety Features

Ground-fault protection should always be working. Press the test and reset buttons to check the outlet or breaker functionality. If the button doesn’t respond, call a professional.

- Schedule a Professional Checkup

A certified plumber can inspect the inside and outside of the water heater and catch things that aren’t visible to the average homeowner. An annual checkup buys peace of mind.

- Keep the Area Around the Heater Clear

When airflow around the unit is blocked or there's too much clutter, heat can build up. That puts extra stress on the wires and heating elements, increasing the chances of a shutdown.

Putting these habits in place is especially helpful during the colder months when your water heater is working full-time. Giving your system the best conditions to operate means fewer surprises during busy days or when guests are in town.

Warm Water Without Worry in Your Birmingham Home

When your electric water heater fails, it throws off your whole routine. You don’t want to start your day with a shock of cold water, especially when Birmingham’s weather dips in the winter months. Spotting problems early, fixing them right the first time, and committing to regular upkeep can make all the difference.

Taking repair shortcuts with power issues can lead to unsafe conditions or even full system breakdowns. A working water heater should not be a guessing game. Trusting licensed professionals helps make sure repairs are done right, and your system is safe and steady year-round.

Whether it's ongoing resets, weak heating, or full shutdowns, these warning signs shouldn’t be ignored. Addressing issues early and keeping your water heater in good condition helps protect both your comfort and your home’s plumbing system.

Trust our experienced team at Keith the Plumber to keep your electric water heater working the way it should. Warm water comfort is just a call away.

If you're in Birmingham and dealing with ongoing water heater issues, it's a smart move to let trained professionals handle the problem before it gets worse. Our team provides dependable electric water heater services that help keep your home comfortable and your system running the way it should. At Keith the Plumber, we’re here to make sure cold water surprises don’t interrupt your daily routine.

Owner/Operator of Keith The Plumber in Birmingham, AL

Keith Eiland

Owner/Operator of Keith The Plumber in Birmingham, AL

Back to Blog